Home > Lensmaking Tips > How To Get The Greenlight

How To Get The Greenlight

Tom Maybrier by on Tue, Jan 31st, 2012

Squidoo has a really amazing set of filters and algorithms that scan new lenses before we allow them to be published. Some of the info we check is the content of the lens, the content on the pages it links to and the comments in the guestbook. All of this information is then analyzed by our magical, top secret algorithms and sent through finely-tuned filters to double check that any lenses that get published are up to snuff and representative of the high quality lenses we love to have on the site.

Unfortunately, no automated system is perfect and sometimes a perfectly good lens will be held back from publishing. When this happens you’re given the option to “Request a Greenlight.” This sends the SquidTeam a short note with the link to your lens so we can check it out, analyze the data and decide if the computer was right in holding the lens back from publishing. Think of it as a real-person “sanity check“. We offer you a “note” space where you can leave us a message, make your case and share any relevant information you think we should see when making our decision.

Today I’m going to give you some tips on how t0 write a good note and what we’d like to know about you and your lens. This information will help us to make an informed decision regarding the publish-ability of your lens. You don’t need to do all of these, and in fact, you don’t have to do any of them to get your lens approved, but all of this information would be very much appreciated by our hardworking team of real people. The more information you provide, the faster we can help you out.

1. Tell us why you’re qualified to write this lens

Did you draw from a real life experience? Read a really great book that inspired you? Tell me about it! Keep it short but mention why you’ve created the lens and what you know about your subject.

2. Send us the links to any sources you excerpted or your own site

Does your lens have excerpted content from another site? Are you quoting your own blog? Send me the links so we can compare the source with your lens. Our algorithms are fairly sophisticated when it comes to detecting duplicated content but again, they aren’t perfect. They make not be able to tell the difference between a verbatim copy/paste and an appropriate excerpt.

3.  Please and “Thank You” let us know you’re not a spammer

I often see short notes like “it is good and unique content” or “it doesn’t contain low quality” with greenlight requests. As you might expect, those lenses almost never contain good, unique or high quality content.

However, if I see a note that reads: “Dear SquidTeam: I wrote this lens about widgets because I used to work in widget factory” and ends with “Thank you!” I know you’re a real person writing a real lens that most likely deserves a greenlight. I open those tickets first. If all you send in is “it has my original contents”, you can be sure I’m going to save that ticket for last.

4. But don’t just sit on your hands, you have the power!

Don’t think that you have to wait for a greenlight request to get a lens published! Keep editing, re-writing and adding new, original content, then click that big orange “Publish” button!

Check out the links you’re using, there could be all manner of SquidDon’t topics mentioned on them or simply low-quality writing that’s been recycled from somewhere else. I often get a second note from a lensmaster telling me they were able to get their lens in publishable shape before I even have the chance to look at it.

A quick scan of our Scroll of Originality and the SquidDon’t Policy could help you to identify any issues that could be flagging an otherwise great lens. You should also police your guestbook comments for spam – often a lensmaster will update their lens and be unable to publish because they’ve received a few spam comments that they neglected to delete.

You can also head over to SquidU, our unofficial forum for users and ask our friendly community of lensemasters for their help.

Is there anything you’ve done to get a lens in publishable shape? Tips and tricks for creating original content? I’d love to hear about it in the comments.

 

 

photo by [phil h] on Flickr

Comments:

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/mamabush mamabush

    I haven’t had any trouble with this yet, but it’s good to know!  :)

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/daedrea daedrea

    I agree…I’ve been greenlighted for 2/2 lenses and you should give your reason and state your case. If not, basically all you will be dong is cheating yourself of all of your hard work.

    • Anonymous

      Glad to hear it’s worked out for you. Writing a note really is a huge help for the team!

  • http://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=1180458242 Beck Williams-Fletcher

    I did bump up against the filters a few times during my pre Giant squid days – and more often than not, I found that it was a single word that was preventing me from publishing – so if anyone else happens to be having the same problem, I advise that they open their notepad (not Word – it’s too rich for Squidoo) and remove their content, one line at a time, hitting publish inbetween and replacing the line you removed last time until your page publishes because it’s the line you just removed that’s triggering the filters.

    Now take a look at the line you have and see if you can phrase it differently to avoid triggering the filters.

    • Anonymous

      Great tip, Beck.

    • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/intermarks intermarks

      In such a case, I would say, the filter is a bit too sensitive and did not give a clear explanation on what words or phrases that hold back the lens. I have experienced with some forum where when you have posted some words that triggered the filter, you will be shown which word that is not allowed. That will save us a lot of time instead of we have to figure out what words or phrases we have to remove from our lens.

      • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/Becksta Becksta

         Although it would be nice to have a little screen that pops up saying “This is why your lens won’t publish” it’s worth asking yourself if it’s worth us giving up on the quality of the lenses that we currently have to provide this because should that be put in place we are going to get the spammers coming en-masse and it won’t be very hard for them to go viral because you are telling them what they need to do to get round the filters.

        In doing that there’s a huge risk that things will get harder for the powers that be to fight the spammy lenses because as soon as you close one there’ll be another 10 to take their place – surely if you are a genuine lensmaster who is creating quality lenses it’s better to apply for Giant status and have no filter that way than it is to tell everyone exactly what they are doing wrong so that they can work around the system that’s there to ensure the quality of our lenses.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/Serenia Serenia

    Yes I only had trouble with 2 lenses hitting the filter before I became a giant squid, and had no trouble getting those 2 lenses greenlighted.
    One was over the word Maquis – which the filter disallows with relation to gambling. However Maquis is also a very important part of Star Trek Voyager – which is totally unrelated to gambling. HQ greenlighted that lens for me within 24 hours.
    The other word was the P and W words for a sex worker and I had to find a new word or phrase to use. I didn’t have to get that lens greenlighted as the lens was published once I changed the bad word.

    • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/Becksta Becksta

       Now you have me wondering why you’d need to use those words in a lens.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/kevinw1 kevinw1

    Is it still the case that, if a lens needs to be greenlighted in order to be published, any time you edit that lens later on it will need to be re-greenlighted? I know some folks have had trouble with that.

    • Anonymous

      Hi Kevin – As long as the new content doesn’t trip the filters, the original greenlight should remain valid.

      • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/ibakir ibakir

        what do you mean by doesn’t trip the filters please?

    • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/manlalakbay manlalakbay

      Actually, one of my lenses had been greenlighted before and then after few months of not editing it and suddenly I modified and added a short updated materials it said that my lens has low-quality content. I wonder what went wrong coz I did everything I need to do and return the original post without the added updated content.. Sitll that lens is already published but can’t be edited and republish again. I know how to work around when the filter said that there are spammy words on my lenses and I successfully fixed them. But this one is different. They allowed it before and greenlighted but now I’m having a hard time fixing it. Anyway, thanks for opening this topic guys! :)

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/zillermil zillermil

    If something I wrote was originally published but didn’t get many hits, will it go to red? Two lenses I wrote a while ago are now suddenly red, and I can’t figure out why, unless it’s ranking.

    • Anonymous

      You’re thinking of Featured vs. Work in Progress. You’re correct, if a lens doesn’t receive enough traffic and the content isn’t kept fresh eventually it will move into “Work in Progress” status. You can find a ton of information about this at squidoo.com/WIP

      • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/zillermil zillermil

        Okay, thanks. I just was reading more about the locked thing and realized it didn’t apply to me — I hadn’t gotten emails, and it was on things like hula hooping, so I was pretty sure it wasn’t hitting any of the spam filters. But thanks for clearing it up for me!

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/kelseyschultz kelseyschultz

    I just got hit by the spam filter yesterday when I tried publishing my lens on the movie “Wrath of the Titans”. Basically for the lens I did what I normally do for my lenses, however it may be the fact that I used Amazon.com’s Instant Video links instead of DVD links? I’m really confused and frustrated about this one.

    • Anonymous

      It could be any number of reasons. Perhaps there’s already a lens on the site that’s similar to yours? Is there anything unique or new you can add? Maybe some modules you don’t normally use?

      • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/kelseyschultz kelseyschultz

        I just double checked a couple of the top lenses for it, and I think it’s because of the photos I’ve used and a few of my links. Definitely understand why it was blocked by the spam filter! Thanks!

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/pattywatty8 pattywatty8

    Today, I tried to make the third lens in my Introduction to Flash series and even though the first 2 gave me no trouble, the third one is. I think it is because the title contains the words Frogger and Variable.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/JesPiddlin JesPiddlin

    I will try to remember this, in case I ever have to utilize it.  I hope I never do, but just in case…  Thanks!

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/Jewelsofawe Jewelsofawe

    I had this happen to a lens and I sent in a note and got a very fast response and green light. I’m glad we can send in a note.

    • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/princesshennessy princesshennessy

      Hi Jewelsofawe, I just experienced the same thing it’s good to know you can respond and get a response I am going to try that now thanks!

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/djroll djroll

    The comments left have been of great help.  Things I never knew about.  Thanks.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/bluewren56 bluewren56

    I haven’t had any trouble with the lens filters, but good to know what to do if one does.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/thomanna thomanna

    I haven’t had to use it yet, but I’m glad I know about it now. Thanks for the information.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/carolinespears carolinespears

    It’s good to know

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/parwatisingari parwatisingari

    This helps.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/RLWalker RLWalker

    From what I’ve gathered this is basically the summary of this entire page:
    Keep those nails clipped, no chewing bubble gum, cellphones off. Also some other things are disallowed and not in the rule book but if you happen to figure those out by yourself I’ll give you a gold star for being clever. Otherwise you’ll have to clean my chalk board and duster to gain favor by me. A sweet juicy Apple occasionally would also improve your chances. That’s it kids, get to work.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/BethSmith BethSmith

    These comments are awesome for a newbie at Squidoo…thanks!

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/deanification deanification

    I’ve just launched my first lens so im glad to have come across this now rather than later it’s good to know

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/athena2011 athena2011

    I’ve never encountered this, however it is good stuff to know just in case. Thanks.

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/kierangee kierangee

    Good to know there’s a human being to override the computer when needed! I hope I can avoid any problems with my lenses but, if I ever get any, I will run for the Greenlight as fast as possible!

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/LooLooBird LooLooBird

    This is good to know, and thanks for the advice!

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/paullenton paullenton

    I have. I took a few links off and “decommercialized” it a bit and it went through. There were too many links to “spammy” websites. I learnt that lesson!

  • http://www.squidoo.com/lensmasters/Melcar Melcar

    Great infor for learning new stuff about Squidoo and its filters, I just got two of my lens green lit today so I’m stoked. just took my time and put the work in.

Official news and updates from the Squidoo Team

Connect with SquidooHQ